In a competitive market, the best house doesn't always go to the highest price. It goes to the buyer who is prepared, writes an accurate offer, and gives the Seller confidence. Here's how I help my buyers do that, in three stages, plus why a backup offer can still win you the house.
Stage 1: Preparation
- Know Your Wants and Needs: Ask your real estate agent to conduct a buyer consultation to fully narrow what is critical in your home search.
- Know Your Budget: Ask your lender for a Loan Estimate for the amount you expect to pay for a house and confirm it is what you expect (don’t forget closing costs!).
- Obtain a Pre-Approval letter: This is different from a pre-qualification letter. Your lender will request documents such as W2’s & Tax Returns.
- Be Ready to Act: Homes located in high demand areas and priced at market value sell quickly.
- Hire a REALTOR®: Have a local, full-time certified REALTOR® who is in the know about inventory, prices, and competitiveness in your target market.
New to buying here? Start with my step-by-step guide, How to Buy a Home in Northwest Arkansas.
Stage 2: Offer Accuracy
- Legal Description: Ensure your agent thoroughly reviews the listing and public records to accurately capture the correct parcel number(s), legal description, and lot & block numbers.
Stage 3: Power Up Your Offer
- Know What Is Important to the Seller: Your agent should speak with the Listing Agent to learn which of the following items is important to the Seller.
- Know the Competitive Context: Your agent should ask the Listing Agent if other offers are expected (they do not have to disclose but often do). Also take into account how many days the home has been on market. Finally, your agent should assess local “comps” to determine how competitive the asking price is.
- Always Include a Pre-Approval Letter: Sellers fear contract termination due to Buyer’s failure to obtain financing and start the listing over. A pre-approval letter gives them confidence to accept your offer.
- Attach a Personal Letter to Your Offer: Demonstrating your enthusiasm for the property will give the Seller confidence you will make it to the closing table. A personal letter can give you the edge when head-to-head against a similar offer. Be sure not to violate any fair housing rules.
- Consider Paying Your Own Closing Costs: Not asking the Seller to contribute to closing costs strengthens your offer.
- Offer a Quick Close or Delayed Occupancy: Offering to close sooner than 30 days is a positive for many Sellers. Alternatively, there may be situations where Sellers appreciate more time to move out and find their next home using delayed occupancy.
- Consider a Non-Refundable Deposit: You may include earnest money in the offer that converts to a non-refundable deposit 3 days following the completion of the Inspection & Repair contingency period.
- Consider an Appraisal Waiver: This waives your right to terminate in the event the house does not appraise for the contract purchase price. Attach a proof of funds letter from your lender to assure the Seller can cover an appraisal gap.
- Use an Escalation Clause: This is a fixed amount you offer to pay above any other offer the Seller receives up to a certain value (ex. Buyer will pay $1,000 over highest offer not to exceed $400,000).
- Always Get an Inspection: You never want to waive your right to an inspection contingency, however you can set limitations that are attractive to the Seller, such as:
- Buyer will not request any repairs (meaning your inspection will be pass or fail)
- Buyer will not request a repair unless repair item cost exceeds $1,000 (i.e. no ticky-tacky repair requests)
- Buyer will not terminate unless estimated repairs exceed $10,000
Not every strategy fits every house or every Seller. Your agent should help you pick the ones that make your offer stand out without taking on more risk than you're comfortable with.
Backup Offers: Still in the Game
What if the house you want is already under contract? Submit a backup offer anyway. Here's a real story.
I met my buyer client at an open house near the University a couple months ago; he told me "We like old houses." Fast forward one month, we meet at the Keller Williams office on College Ave. to discuss what type of house he and his wife are looking for in Fayetteville.
I told him what I tell all of my clients: Take your time. There is no pressure from me, but when THE house you want hits the market, I will jump all over it and work hard to win it for you. Even if it takes a year, I'll be here for you. What happened next was...unexpected.
My client left the KW office to grab lunch at the Ozark Natural Foods CoOp, taking the scenic route through the Fayetteville Historic District. He saw a listing sign at a house he thought sold months ago, so he calls me to ask if we can see it after work. The listing shows PENDING on the MLS so I call the agent to see what's up.
"You must be psychic" the listing agent says, "I'm trying to update the listing to accepting back up offers right now.”
After being under contract for over 45 days, the sellers were ready for an alternative buyer. We used several buyer strategies in our offer (the ones above) and were selected as Position #2, which is subordinate only to the existing offer. 30 days later, we closed!
311 E Prospect is almost 100 years old. When College Ave was expanded, it was moved from College to the corner of Prospect & Willow Ave. My buyers couldn't be happier but they did apologize that it didn't take a year (more like an hour!) Seems to me God teed that deal up for us and I am grateful.
The Bottom Line
A winning offer starts with preparation, gets the details right, and gives the Seller every reason to say yes. And if you miss out the first time, a strong backup offer can keep you in the game.
Ready to write an offer that wins? Text "71B" or book a call with me below.

